DailyWorld News - Sedition Law DailyWorld News - The First International Newspaper From India https://dailyworld.in/ Fri, 20 Nov 2026 08:33:48 +0530 en https://dailyworld.in/sedition-law/experts-in-n-e-point-to-misuse-of-sedition-law-to-choke-legitimate-dissent-436361.html Experts in NE point to misuse of sedition law to choke legitimate dissent By Sujit Chakraborty AgartalaGuwahati June 11 Though not many sedition cases have been reported from the northeastern states lawyers and experts in the region felt that the law must be abolished so that the party in power could not use sedition to suppress voices of dissent Three youths were arrested in November 2021 in Cachar district in Bengalidominated southern Assam for allegedly defacing a government hoarding in Assamese The Assam police arrested journalist Anirban Roy Choudhury and Barak Democratic Front BDF chief convener and lawyer Pradip Datta Roy in November 2021 after they criticised police action and the Assam government for using the Assamese language instead of Bengali in government hoardings Choudhury and Datta Roy have been charged under 124A sedition 153A promoting enmity between different groups and other stringent sections of the Indian Penal Code IPC Choudhury had written an editorial in his news portal Barak Bulletin criticising the use of Assamese language and Datta Roy objected to the use of only Assamese language in government hoardings about the Jal Jeevan Mission Choudhury got bail from the court within a few hours on the day of his arrest but Datta Roy was in jail for 11 days before getting bail Both Choudhury and Datta Roy argued that the Assamese language was used in government hoardings undermining the Assam Official Language Amendment Act 1961 Choudhury in his editorial also flayed sociocultural organisations and the civil society of Barak Valley for not standing up to the alleged imposition of Assamese in the region The Language Act stipulates the use of Bengali for administrative and various official purposes in Bengalimajority Barak Valley or southern Assam which comprises the three districts of Cachar Karimganj and Hailakandi Datta Roy a senior lawyer of the Gauhati High Court told IANS that after the historic language movement of 1961 in which 11 people lost their lives in police firing Assams Language Act was amended making Bengali the official language of Barak Valley inhabited by more than four million people mostly Bengali Putting up government hoarding written in Assamese violated the Language Act Three more people were martyred when massive protests were undertaken in 1972 and 1986 against the conspiracy of imposing Assamese language in the Bengalidominated Barak Valley region Datta Roy said Demanding immediate abolition of the sedition law Datta Roy said that it has been misused by the party in power against its opponents and critics Another senior lawyer of the Tripura High Court Purushuttam Roy Barman said that the colonial law under the IPC was enacted by the British in 1870 and in 2022 the Supreme Court asked the government to suspend the Act for the time being He said that recently the Law Commission in its 279th report has recommended the retention of section 124A of the IPC which contains the law of sedition Commission has recommended enhanced punishment for such offences in the name of national security Seven years to life imprisonment recommended by the Law Commission Roy Barman who is also the founder Secretary of the Tripura Human Rights Organisation told IANS He said that in recent years with the detention of many people in different parts of the country the government misused the law to suppress different voices Criticising government policies and decisions or to express the voice of dissent is always permitted as per article 19 2 of the Constitution Freedom of speech is the right of every citizen enshrined in the Constitution said Roy Barman who is the president of the Tripura High Court Bar Association Demanding the immediate repeal of the law he said that criticising the government is not an act against the nation Curtailment of free speech would never strengthen democracy he pointed out A Congress leader in Agartala said that the BJP government was planning to make the law more draconian and wanted to send out a message before the next general election that it would be used against Opposition leaders The CPIM politburo considers the recommendations of the Law Commission on tweaking the sedition clause of the IPC to be inconsistent with and negating the Supreme Courts observations The Supreme Court had stayed the operation of the Sedition Act until the Union government took appropriate legislative steps to remove this anachronistic law from the statute books The Law Commission however appears to have further strengthened the provisions of the sedition law by extending the minimum jail term from the earlier three to seven years These recommendations are ominous as they come in the background of the manner in which the ED and CBI are being brazenly misused to target leaders of the opposition parties the CPIM politburo said in a statement The Left party demanded the repeal of the anachronistic sedition law Sujit Chakraborty can be contacted at sujitciansin IANS https://dailyworld.in/sedition-law/experts-in-n-e-point-to-misuse-of-sedition-law-to-choke-legitimate-dissent-436361.html Sun, 11 Jun 2023 18:40:00 +0530 https://dailyworld.in/sedition-law/with-12-cases-out-475-filed-nationally-from-2014-21-wb-more-tolerant-of-dissent-436363.html With 12 cases out 475 filed nationally from 201421 WB more tolerant of dissent By Sumanta Ray Chaudhuri Kolkata June 11 West Bengal seems to have a more relaxed attitude with regard to cases related to sedition laws The latest report of the National Crime Records Bureau NCRB giving figures up to 2021 says that only 12 sedition cases have been filed in West Bengal between 2014 and 2021 The figure is just 25 per cent of the total 475 sedition cases filed throughout the country during the same period As per the NCRB report during the same period from 2014 to 2021 just five persons were chargesheeted But not a single person was convicted As per the reports Bengals picture was especially rosy in 2020 During that period just two sedition cases were registered in the state which was just 27 per cent of the total 73 cases filed on this count in the country The situation in West Bengal appeared especially better when compared to states like Assam Karnataka and Uttar Pradesh which recorded a significantly higher number of sedition cases during the same period The figures however were higher when compared with those of states such as Odisha Maharashtra Sikkim or Tripura which reported singledigit registered cases or states like Meghalaya which did not report a single such case during that period However there was a bad patch for the state in 2015 when West Bengal topped among all the states in sedition related arrests In that year West Bengal recorded as many as 53 arrests on charges of sedition and waging war against the state which was the highest among all Indian states and also 2236 per cent of the total 237 arrests throughout the country on the same charges State government officials believe that there had been a major reason for the sudden rise in the number of sedition arrests in West Bengal in 2015 During a major part of 2015 the investigation continued into the blast at Khagragarh in East Burdwan district of West Bengal on October 2 2014 Probably that was the major reason why the number of sedition related arrests suddenly increased in that year pointed out a senior official who did not wish to be named Trinamool Congress legislator Tapas Roy feels that the maximum misuse of the sedition law has been in BJPruled states like Uttar Pradesh and Assam where the police filed sedition cases indiscriminately He added that in West Bengal the government does not believe in silencing the opposition through misuse of sedition laws We practice what we preach which is evident from the records of a Union government outfit he said BJPs state spokesman in West Bengal Samik Bhattacharya says that the figure is just a small part and does not really reflect the true picture of how the law is misused in the state West Bengal is the only state where the opposition political parties always have to approach the court to get permission for conducting peaceful public meetings and rallies In West Bengal the state government follows two sets of rules one which is for the ruling party and the other for the opposition parties he added Calcutta High Court counsel Kaushik Gupta explained that a person may be booked under the sedition law by any Central and state security enforcement agency So it is not always necessary that in a particular year or time period the number of sedition cases in a particular state rises just because the state law enforcement agencies apply its provisions indiscriminately But of course generally the number of such cases is averagely lower in states where the state government applies the provisions of the law judiciously he said IANS https://dailyworld.in/sedition-law/with-12-cases-out-475-filed-nationally-from-2014-21-wb-more-tolerant-of-dissent-436363.html Sun, 11 Jun 2023 18:46:00 +0530 https://dailyworld.in/sedition-law/assam-mla-akhil-gogoi-and-his-struggle-against-sedition-law-uapa-charges-436364.html Assam MLA Akhil Gogoi and his struggle against sedition law UAPA charges By Tanuj Dhar Guwahati June 11 Between 2014 to 2019 Assam reported up to 54 cases of sedition after a wave of protests against the Citizenship Amendment Act CAA Some prosecutions were brought against individuals for their social media posts that were deemed to be proPakistan or antiIndia While those who violated the first two categories attracted some public attention the majority of young people accused of sedition for their social media posts were from lowerclass families and went unnoticed Since 2017 till 2021 activistturnedSivasagar MLA Akhil Gogoi has been charged with numerous seditionrelated offences the majority of which stem from his protests against the 2019 Citizenship Amendment Act He was jailed for quite a long time after he was arrested amid the antiCAA protests in December 2019 Gogoi fought the 2021 Assembly election from jail and won as an independent candidate In 2017 Assam reported 19 instances under Section 124A It documented 17 sedition cases each in 2018 and 2019 There has only been one sedition case reported in the past three years Assam is the state where sedition laws are employed the most frequently both statistically and qualitatively according to Gogoi He said Here sedition accusations are brought against everyone who disagrees with the BJP Communalism is another element at play in this situation Although sedition accusations were made against individuals under the preceding 15year Congress administration as well there is a distinction in the types of claims made in the charges According to reports sedition charges against people in the past were connected to terrorism The majority of these prosecutions were brought against individuals who were allegedly connected to rebel organisations such as the United Liberation Front of Assam ULFA Akhil Gogoi was also slapped with Unlawful Activities Prevention Act UAPA and he is now on bail Earlier in 2021 a special court in Assam discharged him of UAPA charges however later the Gauhati High Court set aside the special courts judgement and the case against the legislator has been continued He moved to the Supreme Court seeking quashing the High Court judgement But the top court of the country upheld the High Court order though it granted bail to Gogoi in April this year On April 19 a Supreme Court bench of justices V Ramasubramanian and Pankaj Mithal rejected the National Investigation Agencys NIA arguments and said that the situation was appropriate for granting bail It stated that the investigation into the case was complete and that there was no evidence to suggest that Gogoi had engaged in any illegal behaviour since being let go The court order mentioned In this case the investigation is over and the petitioner is not yet a convicted criminal Therefore we do not think that any purpose will be served in allowing the special court to remand him to custody and then enabling him to move an application for bail The two judges bench also said the Sivasagar MLA will remain out on bail during the period of trial meeting the special courts conditions However Gogoi said I am ready to go to jail again As I am vocal towards the largescale wrongdoings of the BJP government they will try their everything to put me behind the bars IANS https://dailyworld.in/sedition-law/assam-mla-akhil-gogoi-and-his-struggle-against-sedition-law-uapa-charges-436364.html Sun, 11 Jun 2023 18:52:00 +0530 https://dailyworld.in/sedition-law/why-sc-red-flagged-sedition-case-against-rebel-ysr-cong-mp-andhra-news-channels-436365.html Why SC redflagged sedition case against rebel YSR Cong MP Andhra news channels By Mohammed Shafeeq Amaravati June 11 Sedition charges against a rebel MP of Andhra Pradeshs ruling YSR Congress Party YSRCP best exemplifies why the state registered maximum number of cases in the country under section 124A of the Indian Penal Code IPC in 2021 According to National Crime Records Bureau NCRB Andhra Pradesh topped the list of states in sedition cases in 2021 The southern state accounted for 29 sedition cases out of total 76 registered in the country during that year Manipur and Nagaland were at the second position with just seven cases each Andhra Pradesh is one of the five states with most sedition cases between 2014 and 2021 The state recorded 32 cases during the period NCRB statistics show that from 2014 to 2018 only three sedition cases were booked in the state No case under IPC section 124A was registered in the state in 2019 and 2020 The YSRCP government headed by YS Jagan Mohan Reddy has come under flak for slapping sedition charges against political opponents critics and even media organizations Leader of Opposition and former Chief Minister N Chandrababu Naidu says that the sedition case is part of the Jagan governments autocratic tactics to silence all dissenting voices in the state The cases booked in 2021 include one against Raghu Rama Krishna Raju the rebel MP of the ruling party for his remarks against Chief Minister Jagan Mohan Reddy Two Telugu news channels were also booked for sedition for airing MPs views The CID had registered a suo moto case against Raju a Lok Sabha member from Narsapuram under sections 124 A sedition 153A Promoting enmity between different groups on grounds of religion race place of birth residence language etc and doing acts prejudicial to maintenance of harmony 505 statements conducing to public mischief read with 120 B criminal conspiracy According to the CID there was information against Raju that he had been indulging in hate speeches against certain communities and promoting disaffection against the government A preliminary enquiry has been ordered by ADG CID PV Sunil Kumar IPS It was found that through his speeches Raju was indulging in a systematic schematic effort to cause tensions among the communities and by attacking various government dignitaries in a way which will cause loss of faith in the government which they represent There is hate speech against communities and social groups also which was used to foment social and public order disturbances in conspiracy with a few media channels the CID had stated Raju was arrested on May 14 2021 from his residence in Hyderabad and shifted to the regional office of CID in Guntur on the same day The MP who had undergone a heart bypass surgery approached the Supreme Court alleging that he was tortured in state police custody The state government however had dismissed the allegation of police torture and also defended its action of registering FIR against the MP The state government said It is not a onetime slip or an error of judgment but the statements by Raju have been made in furtherance of a deliberate design and a conspiracy hatched by several individuals including the petitioner herein to create unrest in the State by dividing people on the basis of caste and religion In doing so Raju abused his authority and reach as a public person to create enmity between various class of citizens and excite disaffection towards the government the state maintained Its affidavit further stated that being a MP does not offer any immunity to the petitioner On the contrary being an elected representative to the Lok Sabha the Petitioner owes a higher level of responsibility the state submitted In his petition Raju claimed that his right to criticize the government was part of his fundamental right to free speech But the state government argued that such a right cannot extend to creating a situation where public order is disturbed It produced speeches made by Raju over the past one year encouraging people of one religious community to beat and kill members of another religious group The arrest was not a knee jerk reaction The words and actions of the petitioner MP were manifesting in actual violence across the state It was then the state decided to register FIR It is a settled position of law that the police can register an offence suo moto The petitioner cannot be heard to say that the state ought to have waited with folded hands till an actual complaint was filed the state government added The Supreme Court had later granted bail to Raju observing that the report of his medical examination indicated that he may possibly have been illtreated in custody The court had also asked him to cooperate with the investigation The action against the MP came after he openly criticised the governments handling of the Covid19 crisis and even demanded cancellation of bail granted to the Jagan Mohan Reddy in a corruption case The MP alleged that the case was booked against him out of personal vendetta Raju wondered how a case of sedition could be booked against him for speaking out against the misrule and corruption of the government He pointed out that the Supreme Court has already observed that the section relating to sedition is useless and it should be scrapped In the same case the Supreme Court stayed coercive action against two TV channels TV5 and ABN Andhra Jyothi who were accused of sedition The Supreme Court had observed the broadcasting of programmes by TV channels and publication of views by print media however critical of government may not be seditious The apex court also stated that it would also endeavor to define sedition in the context of such charges being invoked against media Its time we define the limits of sedition Justice DY Chandrachud who is now the Chief Justice of India observed in 2021 We are of the view that provisions of 124A sedition and 153 promoting enmity between classes of the IPC require interpretation particularly on the issue of the rights of press and free speech observed the bench headed by Justice Chandrachud Last year the Andhra Pradesh CID had served notice directing him to appear before it in the sedition case However the MP had sought time to appear The MP alleged that the government was scared as the notice was issued to him after he announced that he will visit Narsapuram While no further progress was made in the case the MP moved Andhra Pradesh High Court in February 2023 seeking directions to order a probe by the CBI or SIT against officers of CID who subjected him to custodial torture He said the medical board set up by the Supreme Court with army doctors also confirmed custodial torture IANS https://dailyworld.in/sedition-law/why-sc-red-flagged-sedition-case-against-rebel-ysr-cong-mp-andhra-news-channels-436365.html Sun, 11 Jun 2023 18:59:00 +0530 https://dailyworld.in/sedition-law/from-caa-critics-to-journos-covering-hathras-rape-up-govt-uses-sedition-law-recklessly-experts-436367.html From CAA critics to journos covering Hathras rape UP govt uses sedition law recklessly Experts Lucknow June 11 Uttar Pradesh became familiar with the sedition law when protests began over the Citizenship Amendment Act CAA in 2019 The sedition law Section 124A deals with words signs or visual representation that brings or attempts to bring into hatred or contempt or excites disaffection against the Government and can be punished by imprisonment for life with a fine or imprisonment that may extend to three years with a fine Uttar Pradesh witnessed a surge in sedition cases after the CAA protests and then the rape of a Dalit teen at Hathras in 2020 When protests broke out after the death of the 19yearold Dalit victim of a brutal gang rape in Hathras district in September 2020 the UP government filed 22 cases of sedition against at least 18 unidentified individuals and five known persons including a journalist and a politician Protests had broken out against the UP governments handling of the incident including its decision to forcibly cremate the victim against her family members wishes and in their absence A retired IPS officer who faced sedition charges when he joined the antiCAA campaign said Suddenly it has become a fashion to slap sedition charges against individuals and organizations without even understanding the legal ramifications of the same It is almost as if officials feel that this is the ultimate punishment they can give to a person to please their political bosses The charges are slapped on trivial issues and do not stand in court In UP 77 per cent of 115 sedition cases since 2010 were registered over the last three years Of these more than half were filed on issues of nationalism accusing people of making antiIndia remarks or writing and chanting ProPakistan slogans Nearly 149 persons were accused of making critical or derogatory remarks against Prime Minister Narendra Modi and 144 against Uttar Pradesh chief minister Yogi Adityanath The data shows a 28 per cent rise in sedition cases filed each year between 2014 and 2020 compared to the yearly average of the second tenure of the United Progressive Alliance UPA administration during 201014 The Supreme Court has ruled that no crime of sedition is established under Section 124A unless the remarks said or written have the potential to cause disruption or disturbance of public order through the use of violence thereby overruling the decision of the Allahabad High Court There is no offence unless the statements are likely to cause violence The UP government has used sedition laws to punish its critics by filing 28 cases against protesters and people critical of the amended citizenship laws and its handling of the gang rape in Hathras It was particularly harsh on those criticising the government and party leaders including Yogi and Modi At least 18 sedition cases were filed against 149 such critics The list of those accused in UP of sedition include the former head of the Congress digital team Divya Spandana and Aam Aadmi Party Member of Parliament Sanjay Singh Spandana tweeted a digitally altered photo showing Modi painting the word chor thief on the forehead of his own wax statue Sanjay Singh conducted a survey which he alleged revealed that the Yogi government was working for a particular caste The situation has come to such a pass that even memes tweets cartoons and photographs are attracting sedition laws Journalists and social influencers are bearing the brunt and are being accused of antinational activities A senior high court lawyer who did not wish to be named said Section 124 A is being used very frivolously and recklessly in UP and the purpose is to intimidate and threaten the target I have had cases where the Epidemic Act was invoked in a simple case of defamation The problem is that majority of these cases do not reach the trial stage and are kept hanging so that the alleged accused goes down on his knees A senior superintendent of police presently posted in an important eastern UP district admitted that there has been an overuse of sedition laws in the past few years There is not much we can do because we are firmly ordered to slap Section 124 A on the person However we know that the case will crash in court so that gives us some relief he said IANS https://dailyworld.in/sedition-law/from-caa-critics-to-journos-covering-hathras-rape-up-govt-uses-sedition-law-recklessly-experts-436367.html Sun, 11 Jun 2023 19:06:00 +0530 https://dailyworld.in/sedition-law/for-the-apex-court-exercise-of-free-speech-is-not-the-equivalent-of-sedition-436401.html For the apex court exercise of free speech is not the equivalent of sedition By Sumit Saxena New Delhi June 11 The 279th report of the Law Commission of India recommending the retention of the sedition law insisting that repealing the legal provision can have serious adverse ramifications for the security and integrity of the country has brought the colonial law back into the reckoning On May 11 last year in a pathbreaking order the Supreme Court directed the Centre and all the state governments to refrain from registering any FIR or taking any coercive measures while suspending all continuing investigations in relation to the Indian Penal Codes Section 124A sedition and also directed that all pending trials appeals and proceedings be kept in abeyance The Law Commission of India not only recommended retaining the sedition law but also loosening its definition and enhancing the punishment in terms of jail time The commission cited a slew of Supreme Court judgments in connection with sedition in its report The challenge to the constitutionality of Section 124A came directly before the Supreme Court for the first time in Kedar Nath Singh v State of Bihar 1962 The constitution bench instituted for deciding the same upheld the validity of Section 124A and after taking a detailed account of the history of Section 124A the court explicitly recognised that the state needs protection from the forces who seek to jeopardise its safety and stability Then the court made the following observation This offence which is generally known as the offence of sedition occurs in Chapter VI of the Indian Penal Code headed of offences against the state This species of offence against the state was not an invention of the British government in India but has been known in England for centuries Every state whatever its form of government has to be armed with the power to punish those who by their conduct jeopardise the safety and stability of the State or disseminate such feelings of disloyalty as to have the tendency to lead to the disruption of the State or to public disorder In its report the Law Commission said the Supreme Court in Kedar Nath Singh took note of its earlier decision in Ramji Lal Modi 1957 to observe that the latter judgment throws a good deal of light upon the ambit of the power of legislature to impose a reasonable restriction on the exercise of the fundamental right to freedom of speech and expression The report said The Supreme Court took note of the strict test of proximity as laid down in Ramji Lal Modi and reinterpreted in Ram Manohar Lohia 1960 Thus while laying down the test for sedition the court held that unless the words used or the actions in question do not threaten the security of the state or of the public or lead to any sort of public disorder which is grave in nature the act would not fall within the ambit of Section l24A of IPC The panel said as per the Kedar Nath Singh judgment proof of violence is not essential for establishing the offence of sedition That the accused Kedar Nath Singh was convicted and punished for his speech without any proof of direct incitement of violence or any imminent danger of public disorder is further testimony to the Court adopting the tendency test for interpreting Section 124A of IPC said the report The panel said this objective test of tendency applied by the court entails examination of alleged seditious material present before the court the circumstances and the conduct of the accused This test need not necessarily inquire into the consequences of the alleged seditious expression like actual violence or real impact of the disputed material If the speech or expression is deliberately made and the content is pernicious enough there is no requirement of proof of any overt conduct to establish tendency of violence In the absence of such an inference the Supreme Court could never have upheld the conviction of Kedar Nath Singh said the report The Supreme Court in the case of Raghubir Singh v State of Bihar 1987 held that in order to constitute an offence of conspiracy and sedition it is not necessary that the accused himself should author the seditious material or should have actually attempted hatred contempt or disaffection In the case of Balwant Singh v State of Punjab 1995 the apex court held that mere casual raising of slogans a few times against the state without any overt act which neither evoked any response nor any reaction from anyone in the public does not attract the provisions of Section l24A of IPC The report said Briefly touching upon the issue of freedom of expression and its conflict with reasonable restrictions enumerated in Article l92 the Supreme Court in S Rangarajan v P Jagiivan Ram 1989 held that there has to be a balance between free speech and restrictions for special interest as the two cannot be balanced as though they were of equal weight While invoking the analogy of spark in a powder keg the court held that exceptions have to be construed precisely as deviations from the norm that free speech should prevail except in exceptional circumstances A prayer was made in the case of Common Cause v Union of India 2016 to issue directions for review of pending cases of sedition in various courts where a superior police officer may certify that the seditious act either led to the incitement of violence or had the tendency or the intention to create public disorder The court granted the prayer and directed the authorities that while dealing with Section l24A of IPC they are to be guided by the principles laid down in Kedar Nath Singh said the report The panel said In Vinod Dua v Union of India 2021 affirming the law laid down in Kedar Nath Singh the court held that a citizen has a right to criticise or comment upon the measures undertaken by the government and its functionaries so long as he does not incite people to violence against the government established by law or with the intention of creating public disorder In June 2021 the apex court quashed a sedition case registered against senior journalist Vinod Dua for his critical remarks against the Prime Minister and the Centre in a YouTube telecast The apex court upheld the right of every journalist to criticise the measures of the government and the free speech of a journalist should be protected from charges of sedition On May 11 2022 the Supreme Court in SG Vombatkere v Union of India directed all the state governments and the Centre to keep all pending trials appeals and proceedings arising out of a charge framed under Section 124A to be kept in abeyance The apex court in its prima facie observation opined that the rigours of Section 124A of IPC were not in tune with the current social milieu and were intended for a time when this country was under the colonial regime Sumit Saxena can be contacted at sumitsiansin IANS https://dailyworld.in/sedition-law/for-the-apex-court-exercise-of-free-speech-is-not-the-equivalent-of-sedition-436401.html Sun, 11 Jun 2023 22:05:00 +0530