DailyWorld News - Remembering Netaji DailyWorld News - The First International Newspaper From India https://dailyworld.in/ Fri, 20 Nov 2026 13:52:25 +0530 en https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/rss-treading-netajis-path-for-indias-wealth-creation-rss-chief-391510.html RSS treading Netajis path for Indias wealth creation RSS chief Kolkata Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat pays floral tribute to Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose on his 126th birth anniversary during a meeting at Shaheed Minar in Kolkata Monday Jan 23 2023 PTI Kolkata Jan 23 Netaji Subhas Chandra Boses aim was wealth creation for the country and Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh RSS is exactly treading through that path RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat said while addressing a function on the 126th birth anniversary of Netaji in front of Shahid Minar in Kolkata on Monday Before Indias independence too there were different forces of different political beliefs However their aim was one and only independence But Netajis aim was not just achieving the independence of the country His parallel aim was also the wealth creation for India RSS now is exactly treading through that path for the countrys wealth creation as shown by Netaji he said Speaking on the occasion Bhagwat also said that besides being a leader Netaji was a commander in the true sense No one did anything for him But he gave up everything for the country He had led the people by being among them He was a leader But at the same time he chose to remain in the battlefield along with his soldiers The commanders generally do not go to the battlefield However Netaji came from Singapore to Assam leading his army the RSS chief said Speaking on the occasion Bhagwat also said that it is India who taught the entire world the lesson of unity The entire world is looking at India now and we will have to shape the country towards that path Since its inception RSS has been working for the development of India as an example to the entire world he said However Trinamool Congress state general secretary and the partys spokesman in West Bengal Kunal Ghosh ridiculed the event organised by the RSS in Kolkata Netaji was opposed to RSSs ideology Netaji was in favour of secularism and RSS is propagating divisive politics They have no right to speak about Netaji he said Countering Kunal Ghosh BJPs national vice president and the party Lok Sabha member Dilip Ghosh said Netaji is above all such politics Netaji is a national hero RSS also believes in nationalism and patriotism and is dedicated to work for the country inspired by Netajis ideology Dilip Ghosh said IANS https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/rss-treading-netajis-path-for-indias-wealth-creation-rss-chief-391510.html Mon, 23 Jan 2023 14:28:00 +0530 https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/india-1st-country-to-name-islands-after-soldiers-amit-shah-391565.html India 1st country to name islands after soldiers Amit Shah EDS IMAGE VIA PIB New Delhi Prime Minister Narendra Modi inaugurates naming of 21 islands of Andaman Nicobar after 21 Param Vir Chakra awardees via video conferencing in New Delhi Monday Jan 23 2023 Union Minister for Home Affairs and Cooperation Amit Shah is also present on the occasion PTI New Delhi Jan 23 Prime Minister Narendra Modi on the occasion of Netaji Subhas Chandra Boses 126th birth anniversary named 21 major islands of Andaman and Nicobar after Param Vir Chakra winners on Monday Union Home Minister Amit Shah present on the occasion said that India is the first country to have done this as no other country in the world had named an island after the brave soldiers who fought for the nation Shah said that it is an important day for the three wings of the Indian military He said that the PMs decision to name the islands after the soldiers had worked to connect the country with the memories of Independence Shah said that after the First War of Indepence of 1857 thousands of freedom fighters were held and tortured in the Cellular Jail in Port Blair He called the jail a place of pilgrimage of freedom Shah told that when Netaji began trying to liberate the country by forming the Azad Hind Fauj this part became independent first He said that the Tricolour was hoisted here for the first time by Netaji and the Prime Minister named 21 islands here after those who sacrificed their lives for the country the act of whom would be written in golden letters in Indias history The Home Minister said that Netajis memorial was being announced on his birth anniversary Shah added that many efforts were made to forget Subhas Chandra Bose but those who are brave are not dependent on anyone for their memory He said that lighting the Amar Jyoti had been stopped in the jail and the practice was restarted by the PM IANS https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/india-1st-country-to-name-islands-after-soldiers-amit-shah-391565.html Mon, 23 Jan 2023 17:58:00 +0530 https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/how-netaji-lived-on-as-gumnami-baba-in-the-minds-of-believers-391288.html How Netaji lived on as Gumnami Baba in the minds of believers Lucknow Jan 22 Rarely ever in history has the enigma of a leader lived on for more than 77 years after his demise Subhash Chandra Bose may have died in an air crash in August 1945 but for those who believed in him he lived on and on as Gumnami Baba Gumnami in Hindi means anonymity Many believe that Gumnami Baba was actually Netaji Bose who lived in the guise of a sadhu at several places in Naimisharanya Basti Ayodhya and Faizabad He kept changing places mostly within the city itself Baba as he was called remained a complete recluse and interacted with only a handful of believers who visited him regularly He never stepped out of his house rather room and majority of the people claim to have seen him only from a distance One of his landlords Gurbax Singh Sodhi tried twice to take him to the Faizabad Civil Court on the pretext of some work but failed This information is corroborated by his son Manjit Singh in his deposition to Justice Sahai Commission of Inquiry set up to identify Gumnami Baba Later a journalist Virendra Kumar Mishra too lodged a complaint with the police Gumnami Baba finally settled in an outhouse of Ram Bhavan at Faizabad in 1983 where he reportedly died on September 16 1985 and was cremated two days later on September 18 Strangely there is no proof that any person really died There is no death certificate no photograph of the dead body nor of the people present during cremation There is no cremation certificate either In fact Gumnami Babas passing away was not known to people until 42 days after his supposed death His life and death both remained shrouded in mystery and no one knows why A local newspaper Janmorcha had earlier conducted an inquiry on the issue They found no evidence of Gumnami Baba being Netaji Its editor Sheetla Singh visited Netajis associate Pabitra Mohan Roy at Kolkata in November 1985 Roy said We have been visiting every sadhu and mysterious individual in search of Netaji from Saulmari to Kohima to Punjab In the same manner we also visited Babaji at Basti Faizabad and Ayodhya But I can say with certainty that he was not Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose Despite denials from sources official or others his believers refused to accept that Gumnami Baba was not Netaji Though the Uttar Pradesh government has officially rejected the claim that Gumnami Baba was actually Bose in disguise his followers still refuse to accept the claim The Gumnami believers had moved court in 2010 and brought out a judgment in favour of their petition with the high court directing the UP government to establish the identity of Gumnami Baba Accordingly the government set up an inquiry commission on June 28 2016 headed by Justice Vishnu Sahai The report stated that Gumnami baba was a follower of Netaji but not Netaji A leading surgeon from Gorakhpur who does not wish to be named was one such believer We kept asking the Government of India to declare that Netaji was not a war criminal but our pleas fell on deaf ears It does not matter that the government did not believe in him we did and continue to do so We want to be known as his believers because we believed in him he told IANS The doctor was among those who regularly visited Gumnami Baba and remains his staunch believer In February 1986 Netajis niece Lalita Bose came to Faizabad to identify the items found in Gumnami Babas room after his death At first sight she was overawed and even identified some items to be of Netajis family Babas room was filled with over 2000 articles in 25 steel trunks No one had ever seen them during his lifetime Handwriting expert Carl Bagget was also given the two sets of letters to analyse without being told the identities of the writers After he said they were written by the same man it was revealed to him that the persons in question were Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose and Gumnami Baba Baggett stood by his conclusion and gave a signed statement to that effect Baggett was an authority on document examination with over 40 years of experience and over 5000 cases to his credit Faizabad the epicentre of the Gumnami Baba myth still believes in the story of the sadhu ignoring the findings of inquiry commissions It matters little to the believers that two consecutive commissions headed by Justice Mukherjee and Justice Sahai had declared that Gumnami Baba was not Netaji My father was among those who strongly believed in Gumnami Baba He respected Babas wishes and never tried to forcibly meet him But whenever he passed by Ram Bhavan he would bow his head in reverence If the government of the time did not accept the truth it does not take away from truth said Ram Kumar a local resident Dr Suman Gupta the resident editor of Janmorcha in Lucknow and also a resident of Faizabad said There were people who were in contact with Gumnami Baba and these people strongly believed that he was Netaji There are many who could never see him or meet him but still believe in him It did not matter to them if the facts prove otherwise it was a matter of faith and continues till this day IANS https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/how-netaji-lived-on-as-gumnami-baba-in-the-minds-of-believers-391288.html Sun, 22 Jan 2023 18:08:00 +0530 https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/anita-bose-pfaff-highlights-netajis-faith-in-secular-values-social-democratic-state-391359.html Anita Bose Pfaff highlights Netajis faith in secular values social democratic state New Delhi Jan 22 On the eve of Netaji Subhas Chandra Boses 126th birth anniversary his daughter Anita Bose Pfaff issued a statement on Sunday restating her fathers vision of India based on secular and socialist principles and she also explained why he had to turn to fascist governments for help Even though he died in a foreign country more than 77 years ago and his remains still rest in a foreign land many of his countrymen and his countrywomen have not forgotten him Pfaff noted in her statement They remember him not only in a detached manner as a person who played a role in the struggle for Indias independence Pfaff said Members of all parties across the entire political spectrum parties who share his ideas and his ideology and those who do not pay tribute to him and thank him for his sacrifice for India With their respect and love they repay him for his sacrifice for their country With this preface Pfaff went on to remind Indians that Netaji should be remembered for what he stood for and envisaged for independent India She then spelt out the four pillars of Netajis Idea of India India was to become a modern state respected by other countries Education for all men and women was therefore of utmost importance to him He believed in equal rights opportunities and duties for men and women for members of all religions castes and all social strata This meant the empowerment and emancipation of all disadvantaged people As an individual he was a religious person However he wanted free India to be a secular state where members of all religions would live together peacefully and with mutual respect These values were practised in the Indian National Army and in his own actions He was a politician inspired by socialism who envisioned India to become a modern socialist or in todays terms socialdemocratic state with equal opportunities for the wellbeing of all In his struggle for Indias independence he saw himself forced to seek the cooperation and support of fascist countries who did not share his ideology and his political agenda Pfaff clarified At that time they were the only countries willing to support this struggle against a common adversary Reiterating her demand that Netajis ashes be brought back home from Tokyos Renkoji Temple Pfaff said Men and women who love and admire Netaji can honour him best by upholding his values in their political and personal actions and by welcoming his remains back in India Let us bring Netajis remains back home IANS https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/anita-bose-pfaff-highlights-netajis-faith-in-secular-values-social-democratic-state-391359.html Sun, 22 Jan 2023 23:23:00 +0530 https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/new-look-party-flag-brings-netajis-forward-bloc-close-to-disintegration-390983.html Newlook party flag brings Netajis Forward Bloc close to disintegration Kolkata Jan 21 All is not well in the Netaji Subhas Chandra Bosefounded All India Forward Bloc AIFB with the recent developments indicating an imminent vertical split in the 82yearold party Signs of disintegration in AIFB whose main strength is concentrated in West Bengal first surfaced on April 22 2022 when the top leadership decided to bring about a change in the party flag Despite being a constituent of the Left Front in the state the proposal to change its flag during the twoday national conference at Odisha in April last year gave a clear indication that the party wanted to shed its Communist tag At the time of inception of the party in 1939 the flag had the picture of a leaping tiger against a Tricolour background However later in 1952 as the party came closer to Communist forces of the country it was changed to reflect Communist ideology with the background colour being changed to red and keeping the springing tiger intact and the symbol of hammer and sickle was inserted However 70 years after that in April last year the party leadership decided to drop the hammer and sickle from the flag while retaining the background colour of red In a statement in April this year the Forward Bloc leadership claimed that the change in look was taken to shift from the concept of communism to the partys original roots as conceived by Netaji The hammer sickle symbol on the flag had lent credence to the propaganda that the party was more Communist than Socialist thus preventing it from growing as an independent socialist force While accepting that hammer and sickle continues to be the symbol of the working class the party will have to acknowledge that the size and colour of the that class has changed with the advancement of science and technology where services sector contributes a major portion of the gross domestic product and there is no reason to exclude workers from that sector However that development led to a rebellion within the party in West Bengal where it has the maximum organisational strength though restricted in certain pockets and the first sign of disintegration became evident The rebellion was started by the popular Forward Block youth leader and twotime former party legislator from Chakulia Assembly constituency in North Dinajpur district of West Bengal Alim Imran Ramz who is popular in the legislative circle as Victor He alleged that the decision to bring about the change in the party flag look was taken at the central council meeting of the party without any consultation with the leadership at all levels IANS https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/new-look-party-flag-brings-netajis-forward-bloc-close-to-disintegration-390983.html Sat, 21 Jan 2023 16:07:00 +0530 https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/netaji-research-bureau-in-kolkata-is-a-treasure-trove-of-untold-stories-390984.html Netaji Research Bureau in Kolkata is a treasure trove of untold stories By Sumanta Ray Chaudhuri Kolkata Jan 21 The office of the Netaji Research Bureau at Netaji Bhawan on Elgin Road in South Kolkata which is the ancestral residence of Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose continues to be a treasure trove of untold stories Some of these stories are quite fascinating Take for example the Germanmake Wanderer car through which Netaji made his great escape from this iconic building in the wee hours of January 16 1941 with his nephew Sisir Kumar Bose in the drivers seat The car became famous but very few are aware that this vehicle was not the first choice of Netaji to escape in at a time he was under house arrest with British spies constantly monitoring his activities in and around his house As per the records of the Netaji Research Bureau archive both Netaji and his nephew were confused over the choice between the Germanmake Wanderer and the USmade Studebaker President the secondgeneration model manufactured by the Studebaker Corporation of South Bend Indiana US Netajis initial preference was for the Studebaker President However it was Sisir Kumar Bose who was in two minds about that choice Though for a long journey the Studebaker President with its seating comfort and stronger structure would have got preference over the Wanderer but both had to keep in mind the secrecy aspect That is where the Wanderer with its lesser popularity in those days compared to the Studebaker President became the final choice An extra cautious Sisir Kumar Bose even made a trial run in it from Kolkata to Burdwan and back in December 1940 According to the historian Raktima Dutta Even during the escape Netaji showed his intelligence to hoodwink the British police spies who were keeping a constant watch on his residence After both had entered the vehicle with Sisir Bose in the drivers seat and Netaji in the rear seat Netaji deliberately did not shut the rear left door beside which he was seated immediately after getting into the car This made the guards at his residence think that only one person was travelling in the car as they only heard the sound of the door beside the drivers seat being shut Many such untold stories are archived in the records of Netaji Research Bureau she said Another important record in the archives of Netaji Research Bureau is regarding Netajis observations or rather strongly worded criticism of Mahatma Gandhis decision to withdraw the noncooperation movement at the meeting of the Congress Working Committee on February 12 2022 This followed the Chauri Chaura incident on February 2 2022 where 22 constables of the British police were killed by a group of angry noncooperation movement activists in retaliation for police firing Although following the decision at the Bardoli meeting the Congress withdrew the noncooperation movement with effect from February 25 2022 Netaji could not accept the decision and minced no words in slamming it as hasty and incorrect all of which are archived at the Netaji Research Bureau In Netajis words he failed to understand why the Mahatma used that isolated incident of Chauri Chaura to strangulate the nationwide movement against British rule Netaji also expressed displeasure that the Mahatma took the decision when the entire country was bubbling with the spirit of the freedom movement The Father of the Nation did not even bother to discuss the issue with the regional leadership of the Congress According to him the decision to withdraw the noncooperation movement was nothing less than a disaster since it was done at a time when the public support for the movement was at its zenith Historian AK Das pointed out that the decision to withdraw the movement probably prompted one of the rare occasions when Netaji and Jawaharlal Nehru thought and spoke on the same lines According to Das Nehru was behind bars when the decision to withdraw the movement was taken Pandit Nehru too described the decision as hasty and incorrect and that too at a time when public enthusiasm for the freedom movement was at its peak IANS https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/netaji-research-bureau-in-kolkata-is-a-treasure-trove-of-untold-stories-390984.html Sat, 21 Jan 2023 16:13:00 +0530 https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/netajis-manoeuvres-in-cong-were-in-sync-with-nehru-but-opposed-by-gandhi-patel-390985.html Netajis manoeuvres in Cong were in sync with Nehru but opposed by Gandhi Patel By Sandeep Bamzai New Delhi Jan 21 Small wars are traditionally waged between asymmetrically empowered adversaries one larger and more capable one smaller and less capable when measured in typical geostrategic or conventional military terms This is not to say that small wars necessarily involve limited resources and small units Small Wars Journal suggests that Vietnam was a small war a conflict in no way small in the conventional sense of the term Paradoxically small wars can be quite big when measured in terms of size of formations employed numbers of personnel involved and casualties sustained or amounts of resources expended It is thus the politicaldiplomatic context in which the war is fought that determines whether it is a small war and not the size and scope of resources expended or the specific tactics employed Additionally the politicaldiplomatic context in which the small war is set determines the conflicts characteristics far more than the theoretical or actual military capabilities possessed by the participants The same small wars analogous reference can be used for the bitter political feud that has existed between the Centre and Mamata Banerjees West Bengal The centrifugal force in this political small war has been the appropriation of Bengali icon Netaji Subhas Bose by Prime Minister Narendra Modi to target Mamata as well as the Congress West Bengal has shown its growing importance in national politics over the last decade or so After UP and Maharashtra and with the breakup of Andhra Pradesh it has emerged as the state which sends the third largest block of MPs to the Lok Sabha 42 Members In 2004 it was the Left which offered outside support to the Congress and in 2009 it was Mamatadi with 19 seats who became a part of the new construct of UPA 2 It is another matter that in UPA 1 the nuclear deal saw the Left walking out in a huff and September 2012 saw Mamatas Trinamool pulling out over FDI and other issues While the BJP breezed through on a Modi wave in 2014 and 2019 the TMC has shown great resilience by winning two successive state elections Using the tailored strategic imperative of a Netajipropelled Bengali nationalism the BJP actually made deep inroads in the 2019 Lok Sabha election winning as many as 18 seats a significant jump over two in 2014 In the continuing tower of babble over Netaji there are some important points in history which are ignored constantly Since superficiality and vacuousness are the order of the day institutional memory needs to be given a booster dose so that things are put in the right perspective In many ways 1938 and 1939 were the moment of truth in a large number of Indian Princely States as powerful peoples movements flourished against the highhandedness of the ruling dispensation which directly drew its strength from the Paramount Power The challenge to the troika of Gandhiji Nehru and Patel also came around the same time At the Haripura Congress Subhas Bose became president of the Congress and a year later in Tripuri he forced the issue again despite strident opposition from the trio and won the presidency by 95 votes more than Gandhijis candidate Pattabhi Sitaramayya After Bose won convincingly Gandhi said Pattabhis defeat was more mine than his At Tripuri in March 1939 Govind Ballabh Pant moved a resolution asking Bose to appoint a Congress Working Committee in line with Gandhis ideas Bose in a passionate presidential address on March 10 1939 where very specifically focusing on the Princely States his opinion coalesced with Nehru stated But since Haripura much has happened Today we find that the Paramount Power is in league with the State authorities in most places In such circumstances should we of the Congress not draw closer to the people of the States I have no doubt in my own mind as to what our duty is today Besides lifting the above ban the work of guiding the popular movements in the States for Civil Liberty and Responsible Government should be conducted by the Working Committee on a comprehensive and systematic basis The work so far done has been of a piecemeal nature and there has hardly been any system or plan behind it But the time has come when the Working Committee should assume this responsibility and discharge it in a comprehensive and systematic way and if necessary appoint a special subcommittee for the purpose This was a direct affront to Gandhiji who believed that the Princes represented the concept of trusteeship and should not be disturbed while it found common ground with Nehrus idea of monarchists being antidemocratic and hence resenting the Indian National Congress idea and the ideal of a new India When the session was on Bose fell very ill and was bedridden The presidential election was dramatic and certainly unlike previous humdrum ones The election was followed by sensational developments culminating in the resignation of 12 out of 15 members of the Working Committee headed by Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel Maulana Abul Kalam Azad and Dr Rajendra PrasadAnother distinguished member of the Working Committee Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru though he did not formally resign issued a statement which led everybody to believe that he had also resigned On the eve of the Tripuri Congress events at Rajkot forced Mahatma Gandhi to undertake a vow of fast unto death Gandhi chose not to travel to Tripuri and instead deliberately went to Rajkot The Congress closed ranks against Bose and the best description of what transpired at the fabled session came from Boses brother Sarat Boses sharplyworded letter to Gandhiji on March 21 1939 It was a scathing fulmination What I saw and heard at Tripuri during the seven days I was there was an eyeopener to me The exhibition of truth and nonviolence that I saw in persons whom the public look upon as your disciples Sarat Bose meant Nehru Patel Azad and company and representatives has to use your own words stunk in my nostrils The election of Subhas was not a defeat for yourself but of the high command of which Sardar Patel is the shining light The propaganda that was carried on by them against the Rashtrapati and those who happen to share his political views was thoroughly mean malicious and vindictive and utterly devoid of even the semblance of truth and nonviolence At Tripuri those who swear by you in public offered nothing but obstruction and for gaining their end took the fullest and meanest advantage of Subhass illness Some exmembers of the Working Committee went to the length of carrying on an insidious and incessant propaganda that the Rashtrapatis illness was a fake and was only a political illness The letter was a denouement of the Congress and the way it had treated Subhas Bose At Gandhijis insistence Sardar responded to Sarat Boses letter where he went onto politely dismiss all the charges levelled by Netajis brother All this finally culminated over time in Subhas Bose being disqualified by the Working Committee as president of the Bengal Provincial Congress Committee Bose split from the Congress and formed the Forward Bloc in opposition to the Congress Narahari D Parikh in Sardar Vallabhbhai writes that Although throughout this period the dispute was between the Working Committee and Subhas Bose he and his followers blamed the Sardar for everything he was the main target of their wrath For this the real reason was the Sardars forthright manner for he spoke frankly and bluntly and never learnt the art of pleasing anyone by sweet words In his letter to Jawaharlal Nehru on August 28 1939 Netaji complained If the old guard wanted to fight why did they not do so in a straightforward manner Why did they bring Mahatma Gandhi between us On April 4 1939 Sarat Chandra Bose had written to Nehru along the same lines I believe I shall not be unjust if I say that the members of the Working Committee would have shown greater courage and straightforwardness if they had decided to act on their own and not used Mahatmaji as their cover Their plain duty was to keep Mahatmaji above all controversy as he should be in our political life Both missives slammed Gandhis followers notably Sardar Patel Bose wrote about this painful experience in his essay My Strange Illness Patel was the focus of his wrath in his letter of March 28 too Bose wrote to Nehru Was there nothing wrong in Sardar Patel making full use of the name and authority of Mahatma Gandhi for electioneering purposes The Bose brothers targeted Patel but realised equally that Patel was a stalking horse and proxy for Gandhiji himself The tricky relationship between the closed group controlled by Gandhiji in the Congress Working Committee those days was patently unhappy with the entry of a powerful and popular outsider in Netaji Though Nehru privately and often publicly remained for most part on Netajis right side in this tussle this proxy war resulted in Netaji leaving the Congress and taking up the path of freeing his country from the yoke of British rule by raising an army through a wartime collaboration with the help of the Axis powers inimical to the British Empire The author is the EditorinChief of the IndoAsian News Service and author of four books including Princestan How Nehru Patel and Mountbatten Made India and the upcoming Gilded Cage Years That Made and Unmade Kashmir IANS https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/netajis-manoeuvres-in-cong-were-in-sync-with-nehru-but-opposed-by-gandhi-patel-390985.html Sat, 21 Jan 2023 16:20:00 +0530 https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/for-the-north-east-netaji-remains-tallest-hero-of-the-freedom-struggle-390996.html For the NorthEast Netaji remains tallest hero of the freedom struggle By Sujit Chakraborty ImphalKohima Jan 21 Three years before Indias Independence Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose the nationalist iconic leader of the freedom movement against British rule not only set foot in northeast India but also boosted the struggle against the British Raj Manipurs Moirang 48 km from capital city Imphal in Bishnupur district has a special place in the history of Indias freedom struggle only due to Subhas Chandra Bose as the flag of the Indian National Army INA was unfurled there on April 14 1944 As the local people were celebrating Cheiraoba Manipuri New Year a column of the INAs Bahadur Group Intelligence wing led by Col Saukat Ali Malik reached Tringlaobi a village about 5 km from Moirang A few local leaders went to meet them and ushered them in to Moirang where Col Malik hoisted the Tricolour on April 14 1944 with a springing tiger on it at the historic Moirang Kangla an ancient spot for the ceremonial coronation of the kings Thus Moirang became the second place on Indian soil where the Azad Hind flag was hoisted the first being in Port Blair in the Andamans where Netaji hoisted it on December 30 1943 The INA Museum in Moirang inaugurated on September 23 1969 has a collection of priceless letters invaluable photographs badges of ranks and other war memorabilia that reminds the visitors of the sacrifices made by the INA soldiers under the charismatic leadership of Subhas Chandra Bose Union Home Minister Amit Shah had on January 6 hoisted the Tricolour at the INA headquarters at Moirang on a 165 feet high pole Not only in Manipurs Moirang villagers of different Nagaland villages specially at Ruzazho and Chesezu villages both in Phek district kept the legacy of Subhas Chandra Bose alive According to Dr Samudra Gupta Kashyap a veteran Guwahatibased author and journalist Ruzazho is a small village which a section of local people claim was liberated from the British by the Azad Hind Fauj or INA in April 1944 The Azad Hind government is said to have administered it for a few months thereafter with local historians claiming that Netaji had himself visited the Naga Hills had spent a few days at Ruzazho and had also appointed a local youth Vesuyi Swuro as a dobashi interpreter The INA had apparently also set up a small operational base at Ruzazho for some time in 1944 till the defeat of Japanese forces in the Battle of Kohima A house said to be where Netaji had stayed is preserved as also some artefacts of the Azad Hind Fauj Kashyap told IANS referring to the villagers and historians Kashyap in his recent book titled Untold Stories of the Freedom Struggle from Northeast India said on October 21 1943 Netaji formed the Provisional Government of Free India in Singapore In March 1944 when Japan decided to attack British India the focus was directly on Manipur and for that matter the entire northeastern region While the 115000strong Fifteenth Army of Japan was directed towards India three Japanese divisions and one division of the INA were the first to make a combined march from Myanmar to Manipur The book said that on March 18 1944 the INA moved from Burma Myanmar into India through Manipur targeting Imphal and Kohima The objectives of the Japanese and the INA were different While the Japanese invasion was intended as a preemptive strike to prevent British attempts to take back Burma Netajis idea was that once Imphal and Kohima were captured the INA would march into Assam and Bengal where they would receive a heros welcome and the Indian national movement to oust the British would receive a massive boost the author said in his book The INA soldiers marching alongside the Japanese troops chanted the mantra Chalo Dilli and sang Kadam kadam barhaye jaa while crossing the IndiaBurma border to step onto Indian soil The goal was to see the Indian flag flutter atop the Red Fort in Delhi by driving out the British Kashyap said in the book There is a list available of prominent Nagas who had rendered valuable assistance to the Azad Hind Fauj during the siege of Imphal and Kohima They include Hepuni Asikho Kaikhu Angami Kevialia Kapuphizo Kaikho Raisung Nikhino Mao Saunglou and a young woman called Shiningla Each of the three Japanese divisions had a regiment of the INA with it Netajis concept was that once the INA marched onto Indian soil it would further intensify the freedom movement Prior to that Manipur had already had the first experiences of the Second World War when two powerful Japanese bombs were dropped on Imphal on May 10 and 16 1942 leading to a number of civilian casualties Prisoners escaped from the jail banks treasuries and markets were looted educational institutions shut down and prices of essential commodities skyrocketed Most people left the capital and Imphal became a ghost town The combined JapaneseINA forces stepped into Indian territory on March 18 1944 through the southern hills and the World War finally reached Manipur Kashyap said that 32 Manipuris who were working in Myanmar not only joined the INA under the leadership of L Guno Singh but were also part of the advance party to enter Manipur Of them M Ahanjao Singh B Balhop Sharma M Chaoba Singh and S Yaima Singh were arrested in Churachandpur and shifted to Kolkata from where they were released only after the war ended Many Kuki youth on the other hand were enrolled as informers porters civil suppliers and soldiers the author said In Tripura to pay rich tribute to Netaji a mammoth colourful procession on the occasion of the iconic freedom fighters birth anniversary on January 23 has been held for the past 74 years the largest of its kind in India The procession organised every year by Netaji Subhas Vidyaniketan portrays themes like Netajis contribution and role in Indias freedom struggle the dream of freedom fighters of a united India the countrys cultural diversity and unity harmony among Hindus and Muslims conservation of water prevention of child marriage empowerment of the girl child and awareness about differentlyabled children and others Sujit Chakraborty can be contacted at sujitciansin IANS https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/for-the-north-east-netaji-remains-tallest-hero-of-the-freedom-struggle-390996.html Sat, 21 Jan 2023 16:29:00 +0530 https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/on-netajis-birth-anniversary-eve-trinamool-and-bjp-play-their-political-cards-390998.html On Netajis birth anniversary eve Trinamool and BJP play their political cards By Sumanta Ray Chaudhuri Kolkata Jan 21 As the country is all set to celebrate the 126th birth anniversary of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose politics over the issue is heating up in West Bengal where the great Indian freedom fighter has his roots The ruling Trinamool Congress and the principal opposition BJP have their own political cards to play in the matter The Trinamool Congressled state government has recently announced the decision to set up a Jai Hind Vahini on the lines of the National Cadet Corps NCC This announcement has led to a political slugfest in the state where the opposition parties have denounced it as a blatant attempt to politicize the Netaji issue This is especially so in the backdrop of the recent development in which the office of the additional director general West Bengal Sikkim Directorate NCC had pointed out how the careers of over one lakh NCC cadets have been affected because of the nonpayment of its share of expenditure by the state government According to CPIM central committee member Sujan Chakraborty the Trinamool Congress reportedly has a branch organization whose name is also Jai Hind Vahini So is this yet another attempt to politicize the school education sphere through this move under the garb of paying homage to Netaji What is the justification of this move when the NCC is there he questioned Somewhat on the same lines the BJPs state spokesman Samik Bhattacharya too has criticised the move He said The entire school education system in West Bengal is going through a deep crisis because of the massive teachers recruitment irregularity scam In such a situation this move on Jai Hind Vahini is nothing but a joke in the name of Netaji First the state government should try to revive the education system by cleaning it up Trinamool Congress senior legislator Tapas Roy rubbished the opposition criticism by describing it as an unnecessary attempt to politicize each and every issue Roy said No one is saying that the Jai Hind Vahini will be set up sacrificing the existing NCC scheme This is just to pay homage to Netaji on the occasion of his birth anniversary The opposition in reality does not have any respect for the great souls of the nation and hence they unnecessarily politicize the entire issue Meanwhile Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh RSS chief Mohan Bhagwats scheduled programme to pay homage to Netaji in front of Shahid Minar in Kolkata on January 23 has stirred a controversy in West Bengal Although the RSS cannot be strictly defined as a political force major political parties in West Bengal and even some analysts feel that the saffron camp will surely try to gain political mileage by this move of Bhagwat before the West Bengal panchayat polls in 2023 and more importantly the 2024 Lok Sabha elections According to Trinamool Congresss state vicepresident Jai Prakash Majumdar it is intriguing why the RSS chief for the first time chose to pay tribute to Netaji and more specially why he chose Kolkata as the venue It is clear that the move is to give BJP some oxygen in the state before the panchayat polls The RSS has never shown any respect for Netaji before Even Netaji refused to meet Vinayak Damodar Savarkar Majumdar said The CPIMs central committee member Robin Deb feels that the RSS and the Trinamool Congress have always operated on a mutual admiration basis where Mamata Banerjee describes RSS as the true warriors against the communists and the latter equate her with Goddess Durga This same tradition of mutual admiration is continuing where Netajis birth anniversary celebration has just become a medium Deb added Historian AK Das too cannot recollect the RSS celebrating the birth anniversary of Netaji so elaborately and that too in West Bengal with the Sangh chief himself being present At least history does not speak of any connection or synergy of thoughts between Netaji and RSS But that cannot stop anyone from paying homage to this great freedom fighter But considering the timing with two major elections coming up the coinciding of the event with any political motive cannot be totally ruled out Das said Netajis grandnephew Chandra Kumar Bose who is himself a face of the BJP in West Bengal said that this hypocrisy over the great Indian freedom fighter should come to an end now Either one should oppose Netaji or accept and practice his ideology of secularism and inclusivity true to its spirit he said IANS https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/on-netajis-birth-anniversary-eve-trinamool-and-bjp-play-their-political-cards-390998.html Sat, 21 Jan 2023 16:34:00 +0530 https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/govt-must-not-delay-in-bringing-back-netajis-ashes-chandra-bose-391001.html Govt must not delay in bringing back Netajis ashes Chandra Bose Kolkata Jan 21 As the county is all to celebrate the 126th birth anniversary of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose his grand nephew Chandra Kumar Bose feels that it is high time that the Union government initiated action to bring back the ashes of Indias great freedom fighter from the Renkoji Temple in Tokyo Speaking to Sumanta Ray Chaudhuri he said that this is also the wish of Netajis daughter and economist Anita Bose Pfaff who wants a proper ceremony for the last rites as per Hindu rituals to be conducted in India following the return of the ashes A well known face of the Bharatiya Janata Party in West Bengal Bose says that all political parties in the country should embrace Netajis secular views and end the hypocrisy in the name of paying tribute to the great soul of the nation Excerpts IANS Although there have been demands for bringing back Netajis ashes from Tokyos Renkoji Buddhist temple no government so far has taken any initiative on this count Will you start a dialogue with the current government on the matter Bose My efforts on this count are already on Although the current Indian government under the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi had taken several initiatives to pay homage to Netaji the initiative for bringing back his holy remains is yet to start Successive Indian governments have hesitated in taking a decision on this count probably because many including members of Netajis family like me once refused to accept that Netaji died in the Saigon air mishap in August 1945 But later on behalf of Open Platform for Netaji we went through the findings of different reports in the matter there is no reason not to believe that the unfortunate air mishap was the reason for Netajis death IANS What exactly made your thoughts on the matter change Bose So far there have been a total of 11 enquiries in that matter Now ten out of that 11 enquiry reports conclusively reported that Netaji died in the plane crash in August 1945 These ten reports are the Japanese Preliminary Report in September 1945 the BritishIndia Government Report in October 1945 Figgess Report in July 1946 Harin Shahs private Report in September 1946 Turners Report in October 1946 Indian Independence Leagues private Report in June 1954 Japanese Detailed Report in January 1956 Taiwanese Government Report in June 1956 Shah Nawaz Khan Committee Report in August 1956 and finally Justice Khosla Commission report 1974 So after so many reports no doubt remains on the issue and hence the process of bringing Netajis holy remains back to the country should start immediately IANS What does Netajis daughter Anita Bose Pfaff feel about this matter Bose She is also quite keen about her fathers holy remains being brought back to India In fact she also wishes that a proper ceremony of the last rites of her father following traditional Hindu rituals be performed after the holy remains are brought back to India She is already 80 years old and I think her wish on this count should be fulfilled IANS Recently you have also been vocal about renaming the Indian Army as Indian National Army Have you taken up the matter with the Union government Bose Yes I have already written to Prime Minister Narendra Modi In my opinion that would be the greatest homage to Netaji If the Indian Army is renamed as Indian National Army it will reflect the nationalistic feelings with which Netaji constituted his army meant for freeing India from British rule The current Union government also believes in nationalism and hence I feel that it would respond positively to my plea IANS What according to you is the best way to imbibe Netajis ideology in current Indian politics Bose The principal spirit of Netajis ideology was secularism and inclusivity I am not speaking only of the party that I represent My appeal to all political parties is they should adopt this principle of secularism and inclusivity Else do not just use Netaji as a political medium Either you oppose Netajis views or accept his ideology true to its spirit But let there be an end to the hypocrisy in the name of paying tribute to this great soul of India IANS Do you see a ray of hope on this count anywhere Bose Yes I was in Kochi in Kerala There I witnessed a successful portrayal of the concept of Bharat unity in diversity in Kerala where communal harmony is of utmost importance There I met a crosssection of the society from all religious communities and each one of them felt strongly about national integration This Kerala model should be implemented throughout the country Otherwise disintegration is inevitable IANS https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/govt-must-not-delay-in-bringing-back-netajis-ashes-chandra-bose-391001.html Sat, 21 Jan 2023 16:40:00 +0530 https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/netajis-daughter-eloquently-seeks-closure-on-myth-about-fathers-death-391002.html Netajis daughter eloquently seeks closure on myth about fathers death New Delhi Jan 21 In two powerpacked emotional statements on Indias Independence Day and on the installation of Netaji Subhas Boses statue at India Gate his daughter Anita Bose Pfaff wanted closure on her fathers myth and legacy In the second she wrote with great verve and felicity on her fathers largerthanlife personality and how deeply ingrained he is in our psyche I am gratified to note that a statue of my father Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose will be unveiled on September 8 2022 by Prime Minister Narendra Modi and will occupy pride of place in New Delhi My father fought selflessly for the freedom of India He sacrificed and lost a lot ultimately his life in the pursuit of Indian independence He was a shining example of dedication to the whole of India and all his countrymen and countrywomen Whether as President of the Indian National Congress or leader of the Provisional Government of Free India and the Indian National Army he upheld in no uncertain manner communal harmony Indian unity as well as the emancipation of women and the downtrodden people In this celebratory moment for the family and the followers of my fathers ideals when free India is recognising his valour and heroism by installing his statue at a most central and prestigious location in the heart of the Indian capital I wish to remind Indians that my fathers mortal remains are still lying in Tokyo and have not been brought home to India for a final disposal for over 77 years He died as a result of a plane crash in Taipei on August 18 1945 In 201516 the Indian Government under Prime Minister Narendra Modi declassified all until then not yet declassified Government of India files pertaining to Netaji thereby making available to the public additional facts regarding his death in Taipei on August 18 1945 The same government in a reply under the Right to Information Act thereafter confirmed the evidence and record in the files Such steps should have removed any doubts about what happened to my father and ended the previous controversy once and for all However if the Government of India insists an authoritative DNA test can be attempted on the remains even though this is not really necessary in view of the evidence available Besides it may not be easy to obtain DNA material from cremated remains It was my fathers ambition to experience a free India Tragically his untimely death denied him this wish I feel his remains should at least touch the soil of India and bring closure to the matter A closure was denied my late mother Emilie Schenkl and I hope that it will not be denied to me as well Therefore I appeal to the people of India and to all Indian political parties to unite in an apolitical and bipartisan manner to bring my fathers mortal remains to India I should be happy to visit India at the convenience of Prime Minister Narendra Modi as well as leading persons of the ruling and the opposition parties to discuss facilitating a transfer of my fathers remains to India In the first Anita Bose Pfaff reiterated how she wanted closure on her fathers death by bringing back his ashes from Japan 75 years after India was able to throw off the shackles of colonial rule the three states that were established on the Indian subcontinent celebrate the anniversary of that event One of the most prominent heroes of the independence struggle Subhas Chandra Bose however has not returned to his motherland as yet Netaji as his comradesinarms from the Indian National Army INA fondly and respectfully called him fought for the independence throughout his life within the country and from abroad He sacrificed so much for this struggle including his peace of mind a family life his career and ultimately his life His countrymen and countrywomen thanked him for his dedication and his sacrifice They erected numerous physical and spiritual monuments for him thus keeping his memory alive to this day in admiration in gratitude and even in love Another imposing monument has been erected and is being unveiled in a very prominent location in New Delhi by Prime Minister Narendra Modi on August 15th 2022 the 75th anniversary of Indias independence Motivated by their admiration and love for Netaji some men and women in India not only remember Netaji but they have continued to hope that he had not died on August 18 1945 as the consequence of an aeroplane accident and that he would eventually be able to return to his independent motherland But today we have access to the originally classified inquiries of 1945 and 1946 They show that Netaji died in a foreign country on that day Japan has provided a temporary home to his remains at Renkoji Temple in Tokyo cared for in devotion by three generations of priests and honoured by the Japanese people Many Indians including most of her Prime Ministers have paid homage to Netaji and the INA there as well Modern technology now offers the means for sophisticated DNAtesting provided DNA can be extracted from the remains To those who still doubt that Netaji died on August 18 1945 it offers a chance to obtain scientific proof that the remains kept at Renkoji Temple in Tokyo are his The priest of Renkoji Temple and the Japanese government agreed to such a test as the documents in the annexures of the last Indian investigation into Netajis death the Justice Mukherjee Commission of Inquiry show So let us finally prepare to bring him home Nothing in his life was more important to Netaji than his countrys independence There was nothing that he longed for more than living in an India free of foreign rule Since he did not live to experience the joy of freedom it is time that at least his remains can return to Indian soil As Netajis only child I feel obliged to ensure that his dearest wish to return to his country in freedom will at last be fulfilled in this form and that the appropriate ceremonies to honour him will be performed All Indians Pakistanis and Bangladeshis who can now live in freedom constitute Netajis family I salute you all as my brothers and my sisters And I invite you to support my efforts to bring Netaji home IANS https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/netajis-daughter-eloquently-seeks-closure-on-myth-about-fathers-death-391002.html Sat, 21 Jan 2023 16:45:00 +0530 https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/peerless-patriot-who-also-heralded-the-end-of-princestan-391004.html Peerless patriot who also heralded the end of Princestan By Sandeep Bamzai New Delhi Jan 21 The centrality of Netaji Subhas Bose to the Narendra ModiBengal narrative is irrevocable Netaji was pretty much rediscovered by Modi and the installation of his statue at the Central Vista is proof of concept Netaji was undeniably kept in historys deep freeze for 75 years by the Congress his contributions to Congress ideology and history was never acknowledged adequately by various governments rather he was ignored ignobly Netaji was a patriot with a largerthanlife persona his trajectory after splitting from the Congress was nothing short of sensational Embedded in the Bengali psyche he remains peerless for his revolutionarylike status and militant role in our freedom struggle But what led to the souring of his relationship with Gandhi and Patel and to a lesser extent with Nehru Protected by British power the rulers of princely states neglected their subjects they not only collected rent but also various illegal levies and subjected people to forced labor while squandering away a major part of their states revenues for the upkeep of their luxurious lifestyles denying the masses their democratic rights This infuriated Jawaharlal Nehru In 1927 the All India States Peoples Conference was born to coordinate the peoples movements in various princely states At first the Congress hesitated to take up the cause of peoples movements on legal and practical grounds but Nehru was at the vanguard of change In the end the Fabian Socialist triumphed bringing different instrumentalities to bear against all those who opposed him in his endeavour to create a united and unified India To stampede the princes he used Lord Mountbatten to corral them he used the combination of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel and VP Menon to overturn the Dickie Bird Plan for Independence he used Edwina Mountbatten who in turn chose to pack VP Menon off to Shimla to offer his version instead and got it approved by both Mountbatten and Nehru who as luck would have it were both present in the Queen of the Hills recouping The Haripura Congress session of 1938 is considered seminal for many reasons not the least for Subhas Chandra Boses whiplashinducing speech as the new party president At the same session the Indian States Peoples Resolution provided the basis for one of the most pivotal debates of the Congress session About the proposed Federation under the new Constitution this question was considered to be of utmost importance and occupied the Subjects Committee for five hours in a heated discussion Ben Bradley wrote The concern of the delegates was not merely actuated by the importance of the Indian states in the Federation but at the Calcutta session last October of the AllIndia Congress Committee a resolution was adopted condemning the repression in Mysore state and supporting the heroic struggle of the people in that state This was a crucial time for the Congress itself and Jawaharlal Nehrus stalking horse strategy of using the All India States Peoples Conference AISPC to make deeper inroads into the autocratic princely states which required radical democratisation to free the populace from serfdom and penury The starter pistol had truly gone off and the process of a new India began to be fashioned Bradley writes that subsequently doubts were raised as to the validity of this resolution There was opposition in the AllIndia Congress Committee to the resolution and certain Congress leaders including Mahatma Gandhi stated that the Congress had no right to interfere in the affairs of Indian states and thought that this resolution constituted an interference It was to clear this up that the question was discussed at Haripura Gandhi believed in the concept of trusteeship and how the princes represented this concept in their states visavis their attitude toward their subjects Nehru opposed this and finally the breakthrough benefit came at Haripura not just with this resolution but with new president Boses vehement support of Nehrus vision of an India where the provinces and the princely states would coalesce Bradley goes on to provide a perspective on the actual happenings The delegates representing various Congress committees from the Indian states felt and spoke very strongly for the closer relationship between the people struggling in Indian states and those struggling in British India The Left Wing and the Socialist section of the Congress delegates thought that the mass struggle to win basic civil liberties and responsible government was growing in the states Further close cooperation was essential between the states people and the people of British India to fight the Federation It was also the duty of the Congress not merely to sympathise with the struggle of the states people but to fraternise with them and give active assistance in the fight against the autocracy of the Princes The original resolution moved by Abul Kalam Azad sought to relieve the Congress of responsibility in connection with the present struggle of the Indian states peoples This was covered by the following point in the resolution The Congress therefore directs for the present that no Congress committee be established in Indian states and that internal struggles of the people of the states be not undertaken in the name of the Congress Jawaharlal Nehru batted for the resolution saying it did not renege on the Congress attitude towards the states peoples and added But the question that had become vital was that they had to face realities and march independently towards their common goal Speeches were made by all sections of the delegates strongly condemning this resolution From the delegates coming from Indian states a fervent appeal was made to the Congress not to refuse help to the states peoples in their hard fight against feudal lords and despotic rulers One Congress delegate Jayanarian Vyas from AjmerMerwara asked the Congress high command Would you take away from us what even autocratic rulers or bureaucratic imperialism has not dared to take away namely our right to be in the Congress Pattabhi Sitaramayya in a fighting speech exposed the dangers of the Congress adopting the policy which must follow from the resolution of isolating Indian states and was allowed to move an agreed amendment accepted by Abul Kalam Azad The amendment deleted the clause opposing the formation of Congress committees in Indian states and instead stated The Congress therefore directs that the present Congress committees in states shall function only under the direction and control of the working committee and shall not engage in direct action in the name or under the auspices of the Congress nor undertake internal struggles of the peoples of the state in the name of the Congress For this purpose independent organisations should be started and continued where they exist already within the states Pattabhi suggested that based on this formula all other amendments should be withdrawn On this proposition 11 out of 13 amendments were withdrawn The motion on relations between the Congress and Indian states peoples was then put to vote and carried This resolution represented a retrogressive step particularly at this juncture when British Imperialism was drawing up its final plans to introduce the Federal side of the new Constitution under which onethird of the total seats in the Federal government were to be reserved for the despotic Princes who denied even the basic democratic rights to the states subjects It is at this stage that full support had to be been given to the struggle of the people in the Indian states for democratic rights and civil liberties and to carry this through effectively ways and means of strengthening Congress organisations in the states had to be planned The 70 million people in the Indian states had to be drawn into the Congress as allies of the Indian people in a common struggle for liberation against British imperialism and its allies the despotic princes Nehrus silent opposition to Gandhis concept of trusteeship found new thrust and kinetic energy as both the AISPC and the Congress went full tilt to emasculate the arrogant princes by enlarging the scope of democratisation The author is the EditorinChief of the IndoAsian News Service and author of four books including Princestan How Nehru Patel and Mountbatten Made India and the upcoming Gilded Cage Years That Made and Unmade Kashmir IANS https://dailyworld.in/remembering-netaji/peerless-patriot-who-also-heralded-the-end-of-princestan-391004.html Sat, 21 Jan 2023 17:27:00 +0530